Kezia Dugdale Got Just 5,217 Votes 1642


The Labour Party is being remarkably coy about releasing the actual result of its Scottish accounting unit leadership election, giving only a percentage. The entirely complacent unionist media is complicit in what amounts to a deception. The stunning truth is that in a one person, one vote election among the entire membership of the Labour Party in Scotland plus trades union supporters, Dugdale won with 5,217 votes (out of a claimed electorate of 21,000, many of whom do not exist or could not be arsed to choose between two right wing numpties).

UPDATE: A second Labour figure just rang me to assure me my information – which was from a good source – is wrong. She would not give the actual figure and only said it was “higher”. I offered to take down the post and publish an accurate figure if she would give it, but this was declined.


Allowed HTML - you can use: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

1,642 thoughts on “Kezia Dugdale Got Just 5,217 Votes

1 12 13 14 15 16 55
  • glenn

    Hello Suhayl – always good to see your posts, very nice to see you actually have the time to write here these days.

    This sort of political intolerance you describe is the ruin of many progressive ideas which might actually have been worthwhile, had they been openly discussed and worked upon. Differences and questions should be tolerated. You mentioned earlier about mouthing slogans without understanding their meaning any longer – that surely can also be applied to religions.

    Failure to observe the tenets of faith with sufficient enthusiasm has been seen as enough reason (excuse, perhaps?) to visit denouncements, sanctions, hideous punishment, death and war at its extremes. It is very bothersome to me that human nature will allow sizable proportions to leap into such meting with no little glee. It seems that humans tend towards accepting that there is to be conflict. Perhaps it really is just down to testosterone, urging for a need to fight and find enemies – particularly in cultures where other outlets for satisfying hormonal urges are frowned upon.

    When one sees this among those on “our side” of a political divide, it is quite a disappointment – we like to think of our lot as a bit more tolerant, thoughtful, open to debate. Mr Goss is outstanding in this regard – he’ll remain a gentleman, even during a disagreement. Far better at it than myself, for instance.

    *

    A case in point – about a week back, some young ladies of questionable judgement hijacked a Bernie Sanders rally. A few thousand people had shown up to see Sanders, who is running as a democratic socialist for US president, and garnering great interest, particularly among disillusioned and young voters. Much as Corbyn is doing here, incidentally.

    The two “Black Lives Matter” (BLM) self-proclaimed representatives barged Sanders out of the way, denounced him, the crowd and most of Seattle as white-power racists. This is a particular shame, because Sanders had been fighting for minority rights, probably prior to these protestors’ parents being born.

    Some progressive liberals thought this protest was great – BLM is a serious issue, and now it had more attention, and Sanders has only benefited from the extra attention.

    Other progressive liberals thought it was an outrage – Sanders is the last person the BLM movement should denounce, why not go after La Clinton, or the stinking Republican candidates instead?

    The animosity generated because of a difference in these positions, and the energy with which they argued, ridiculed and denounced the other, was fascinating and terrible to see.

  • Habbabkuk (la vita e' bella)

    “I am not going to give the name of the man who is apparently the sole living former LibDem MP from Birmingham, as it has been suggested that to do so might prejudice a trial.”
    _________________

    With respect, I think the author of the above over-estimates ever so slightly the importance of his comments with regard to any possible forthcoming proceedings.

    ////////////////

    “It may be easy to determine who was the subject of my comment at 7:57 with a bit of googling, but my comments have not accused that person of doing anything wrong.”

    ___________________

    No, you never do, do you. Much more fun just to drop little hints. Reminds me a little of the connection the author of the above made between the accusations against Sir Edward Heath and the fact that two of his yachts were wrecked (one about three years after Heath sold it!) 🙂

  • John Goss

    Just because Resident Dissident does not want to engage in support of his beloved fascists in Ukraine does not mean I’m going to stop reporting what MSM keeps quiet about.

    Kiev has moved heavy artillery closer to the people’s self-declared republics. This is in contravention of Minsk 2. Russia is becoming impatient with the bombardment of lies from the puppet regime in Ukraine.

    http://tass.ru/en/world/815090

    Russia calls on the Ukrainian government to honour the Minsk agreements.

    http://tass.ru/en/world/815083

  • Mary

    I thought I recognized the name of the website, Unfashionista.

    Louise Mensch, a former Con MP, now in NY with her band manager husband and children and one time member of the DCMS committee under Whittingdale’s chairmanship when the NoTW stuff was coming out. Whittingdale has been rewarded by Cameron with the job of DCMS Sec of State.

    She used to write chick lit under the name Bagshawe.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louise_Mensch

    Revolting stuff/slime about Jeremy.
    http://unfashionista.com/2015/08/17/every-dead-british-soldier-is-a-victory-jeremy-corbyns-parliamentary-guest/

    Craig
    Democratic Sham
    July 19, 2011

    If ever proof were needed that our political system is a pretend democracy, the abysmal performance of today’s select committees should remove any doubt. The lack of any tenacious or forensic questioning on just what people knew and just when they knew it, was startling. Rebecca Brooks apparently very seldom visited the paper she edited and had no idea what happened there. Nobody had any idea why they might be meeting the legal costs of assorted criminals. Nobody asked Brooks straight out exactly how much she knew about payments to coppers.

    Most sycophantic of all was Louise Mensch, in her helpful attempts to ask questions revealing that all the News of the World did was the same as the rest of Fleet Street, and it had some good effects, like combating paedophiles. I lost count of mentions of Sara’s Law and paedophiles – no mention of the mob they incited to attack a paediatrician, though. These MPs are so used to asking servile questions at Prime Minister’s Question Time, they don’t seem to realise how they look to the rest of us.

    If anybody had any doubt that most MP’s, News International and the top people at the Met are all part of the same corrupt governing political class, the scales must surely have dropped from the eyes now. What a pathetic bunch of parasites.

    ~~~

    She used to vet the speakers at the Oxford Union

    ‘The students no longer have any autonomy in the the Oxford Union where speakers and videos have to be approved in advance by a solidly and uniformly right wing board of trustees which includes William Hague and Louise Mensch.’

  • nevermind

    Thanks Suhayl, I shall have to do a bit of work this morning and think about the irrelevances we all have lived in during our life’s.
    My point is that without a fair vote we will never get to those who maneuver society and skip the law as they wish, because they can and have powerful allies. there is no difference between a cesspit and a tax haven in my view, both accrue the detritus gathered.

    I don’t think that your points are invalid, or ought to be heard here, its just that I do not agree that the salvation and change will come from the established parties, it will come from a fair vote and a new political landscape. despite the Lib Dems, ehem now strongly coming back they say,,,,being breakfast to the Tory’s coalitions are the way forward.
    I would advocate coalitions to form themselves well before elections, to show a new cordial to the electorate, rather than pursuing a one party goal one would stand on a plethora of policies.

    hang in there, one day it’ll happen

  • Ba'al Zevul

    Kiev has moved heavy artillery closer to the people’s self-declared republics. This is in contravention of Minsk 2.

    Only if the Russians democratic freedom fighters of the heroic Donbass brigades haven’t got artillery within range.

    (2) Pull-out of all heavy weapons by both sides to equal distance with the aim of creation of a security zone on minimum 50 kilometres (31 mi) apart for artillery of 100mm calibre or more, and a security zone of 70 kilometres (43 mi) for multiple rocket launchers (MRLS) and 140 kilometres (87 mi) for MLRS Tornado-S, Uragan, Smerch, and Tochka U tactical missile systems:

    for Ukrainian troops, from actual line of contact;
    for armed formations of particular districts of Donetsk and Luhansk oblasts of Ukraine, from the contact line in accordance with the Minsk Memorandum as of 19 September 2014
    The pullout of the above-mentioned heavy weapons must start no later than the second day after the start of the ceasefire and finish within 14 days.
    This process will be assisted by OSCE with the support of the Trilateral Contact Group.
    (Minsk 2, Wiki)

    The inescapable conclusion from this:

    http://www.osce.org/ukraine-smm/177826

    is that at least on the 16th, each side’s heavy artillery was well within 50Km of the line, and firing.

    Russia is becoming impatient with the bombardment of lies from the puppet regime in Ukraine.

    Not quite sure what business of Russia’s it is, John. Especially as Russia isn’t involved in any way, has no territorial ambitions whatever in Eastern and Black Sea Ukraine, and is particularly nice to stray kittens.

  • Mary

    John Do you have sight of reports carried by this website? Very detailed. Horrendous.

    ‘Introduction by New Cold War.org, August 18, 2015

    The following is a compilation of eleven news reports that provide some overview of the scale of the recent escalation of shelling and other military activity by the Ukrainian armed forces and the extremist paramilitary forces allied with it in the Donbas region of eastern Ukraine.

    Below those news reports is the daily report for August 16, 2015 of the Special Monitoring Mission (SMM) in Ukraine of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE). This typical, daily report is especially lengthy.’

    http://newcoldwar.org/grim-toll-of-rising-ukrainian-shelling-in-donbas-eastern-ukraine/

    ~~~
    There’s no show without Punch.

    ‘A true friend’: Ukraine president asks Tony Blair to take on advisory role
    Unclear whether former British PM will take up offer by Petro Poroshenko, as Blair meets other key figures in Kiev hosted by oligarch Viktor Pinchuk
    http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jun/18/ukraine-president-asks-tony-blair-advisory-role-poroshenko

  • Mary

    An American on the death of a friend and the lack of healthcare in the US.

    He says –

    ‘But of course health care is a privilege in the USA. It is your right, as a US citizen, to have more than 7,000 expensive nuclear weapons on obscenely costly Trident submarines and Stealth bombers, all prepped all the time to destroy life on Earth. It is your right, as an American, to project power and dominance from approximately 1,000 military bases on the sovereign soil of other people’s lands, costing far more than universal health care would ever cost. No other country does this. Find me the Chinese bases in Europe; find me the Russian bases in Oceana or Africa. Look in 153 of the 193 nation-states on Earth and you’ll find only US bases. Look in Todd’s room and you won’t find him. He and thousands of others are sacrificed on the altar of militarism every year.’

    Spot on.

    http://www.counterpunch.org/2015/08/19/toddcare/

  • Ba'al Zevul

    A true friend’: Ukraine president asks Tony Blair to take on advisory role
    Unclear whether former British PM will take up offer by Petro Poroshenko, as Blair meets other key figures in Kiev hosted by oligarch Viktor Pinchuk

    As noted at the time on An Apology. In which you will see that immediately after the visit to Kiev in which this was discussed, Blair flew to St. Petersburg to attend Putin’s showpiece competitor to the World Economic Forum.

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3130590/Blair-shows-credibility-Putin-summit-Former-PM-speaks-vanity-summit-set-Russian-leader-alongside-regime-s-ministers.html

    Mr Blair told the audience of Russian businessmen how they could improve their performance by following the lessons of his delivery unit, which he introduced in Downing Street to speed up school and hospital reforms.

    So I wouldn’t regard Ukraine as any better than Russia on the Blair-approval index.

    The following is a compilation of eleven news reports that provide some overview of the scale of the recent escalation of shelling and other military activity by the Ukrainian armed forces and the extremist paramilitary forces allied with it in the Donbas region of eastern Ukraine.

    But not of anyone else shooting?

    Below those news reports is the daily report for August 16, 2015 of the Special Monitoring Mission (SMM) in Ukraine of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE). This typical, daily report is especially lengthy.’

    To which I linked in the post immediately above yours. August 16th is the latest report to appear on the site: the others may be found immediately below.

    Both sides are breaking the Minsk agreement.

    Don’t bother telling me you don’t read my posts before immediately jumping in to dispute them with a c&p you haven’t read or understood either. I know. It’s obvious.

  • Ba'al Zevul

    Update, latest OSCE report (18th)

    http://www.osce.org/ukraine-smm/178011

    The SMM re-visited two “DPR” and eight Ukrainian Armed Forces heavy weapons holding areas, whose locations comply with the respective Minsk withdrawal lines. At one “DPR” holding area, the SMM noted the absence of two 152mm artillery pieces, whilst at the other, all previously-recorded weapons were present. At Ukrainian Armed Forces sites, the SMM noted the absence of the following previously-recorded weapons: nine towed howitzers (2A65 Msta-B, 152mm); 10 MLRS (BM-21 Grad, 122mm); four towed anti-tank guns (2A19 MT-12 Rapira, 100mm); four self-propelled howitzers (2S1 Gvozdika, 122mm); four towed guns (2A36 Giatsint-B, 152mm); eight anti-tank missile systems (9P149 Shturm-S); and five self-propelled howitzers (2S3 Akatsiya, 152 mm).

    In addition to weapons spotted by SMM UAVS in areas around Mariupol, the SMM observed the following weapons in areas that are non-compliant with the Minsk withdrawal lines: in “DPR”-controlled areas, 18 T-72 main battle tanks – in two separate areas – and a 122mm artillery piece; and, in a government-controlled area, a military-type truck towing a 120mm mortar piece.

    It’s hotting up. I think we can safely forget about Minsk 2.

  • Mary

    I did read your post. You are being patronizing, again. You do not like any contradictions.

  • YouKnowMyName

    “I think we can safely forget about Minsk 2”

    Wonderful, so we welcome neocon initiated unlimited thermonuclear war in Europe; that’s one way to stop people worrying about the economy. Oh, look, a squirrel!

    .

    .

    Vice.com actually sent journalists to interview the foot-soldiers on both sides, the unsurprising news was that both sides’ leaders are lying, UA is still ‘overmatched’ against RU, but UA is such a prize for the neocons that they won’t give up?

  • Ba'al Zevul

    You are being patronizing, again. You do not like any contradictions.

    Back at you.

  • Ba'al Zevul

    Wonderful, so we welcome neocon initiated unlimited thermonuclear war in Europe; that’s one way to stop people worrying about the economy.

    Yup. RT, Sputnik, Voltaire, Global Research and, er, newcoldwar.org, to name but a few outlets sharing journalists with Russian credentials*, would certainly like us to be very afraid of that.

    *here’s one:

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/9146307/Barrister-struck-off-over-claim-that-senior-law-lord-had-him-kidnapped.html

  • Herbie

    “Yup. RT, Sputnik, Voltaire, Global Research and, er, newcoldwar.org, to name but a few outlets sharing journalists with Russian credentials*, would certainly like us to be very afraid of that.”

    Here’s the fascist side in Ukraine fearing something similar:

    ‘We are in danger’: Ukrainian foreign minister says he fears Russian invasion amid claims Putin ‘wants to start World War Three’

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2612817/Putin-issues-new-threat-against-Ukraine-as.html

    Yours seems only a partial account.

  • Ba'al Zevul

    Yours seems only a partial account.

    Very true. Given that Goss is sucking from the Kremlin teat, a little balance seems desirable. I’m providing it.

    Ukraine is suffering from a perceived lack of co-operation from the West, though. It’s probably outgunned now, and if it isn’t, it is (and I am) sure that resources to outmatch it can speedily be wheeled into place by Moscow. So no surprise that it is playing up WW3 to underline the urgency of aid. It wants more help. Putin wants less help for Ukraine, and he’s using WW3 as a threat – rather successfully. Perhaps there’s a basis for agreement there…it’s very much up to them.

    PS. Not all Ukrainians wishing to remain Ukrainian and unscorched are fascist. Some Russians are also fascist, and Putin doesn’t seem to be locking them up. There’s actually very little indeed to choose between the two, socio-politically speaking.

  • John Goss

    Thanks Mary at 9.26 am. I had not seen that particular site but was aware frm other sites what is happening. MSM = three mnkeys. Perhaps Ba’al should read it too. He seems to be under the impression that this killing of civilians is going on daily on both sides.

    As to it being no business of Russia, it is every business of Russia being a long-term business partner, Ukraine being traditionally a part of Russia, and Vladimir Putin having initiated and negotiated the Minsk agreements. What it is no business of is the USA and UK which foment war all over the world and create failed states and civil wars where peace previously existed.

  • Herbie

    What danger is there of the Ukraine thing spilling over into a broader war?

    Your view seems to be that Russian concens about this are merely statements of self-interest.

    You also argue that even Kiev’s concerns are self-interested statements to other objectives.

    Could German concens about a broader war be put down to self-interest.

    American?

    Polish?

    At what point should we take concerns about a broader escalation more seriously?

  • YouKnowNyName

    An interesting development here that is already effective, affecting the MSM

    http://climatefeedback.org

    What if online coverage could be peer-reviewed?
    Using the Hypothesis annotation platform, our community of scientists go through a variety of online media articles and provide ‘feedback’ on the scientific accuracy of the information presented. Readers can view these annotations directly alongside the original texts and see exactly where the article’s information is consistent — or inconsistent — with scientific thinking and state-of-the-art knowledge in the field.

    we just need the online feedback tools on the *rest* of the news that is filtered/poisoned by the nudge agenda and other secret teams
    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/money/news/article-3202652/The-hidden-hand-pulling-financial-strings-secretive-government-nudge-unit-tries-manipulate-behaviour-help-sinister.html

  • John Goss

    Ba’al at 10:06 am.

    Yes I read the OSCE report. It is released by the same two clients Resident Dissident keeps linking to and is anything but impartial. Those clutching at straws will present anything as evidence. I have emailed these people in the past questioning their data. They do not respond.

    Contacts
    Michael Bociurkiw
    Spokesperson
    OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine
    26 Turhenevska Street
    01054 Kyiv
    Ukraine
    Office: +380 44 382 0832
    Mobile: +38 067 4083107
    [email protected]

    Iryna Gudyma
    Senior Press Assistant
    OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine
    26 Turhenevska Street
    01054 Kyiv
    Ukraine
    Mobile: +38 067 4021716
    [email protected]

  • BrianFujisan

    [ Mod: Stuck in spam filter ]
    —-

    Good Piece here From John Hilley, demolishing the Guardian Re Corbyn.

    ” As Moore bewails:

    You should be able to express doubt about Corbyn without risking vitriol.

    Note the coy use of words here: while an entire media effort to bombard Corbyn with abusive distortion can be reduced to “doubt”, responses to it are to be condemned as “vitriol”.”

    http://johnhilley.blogspot.co.uk/2015/08/trashing-corbyn-promoting-brown.html

  • Ba'al Zevul

    From the link you kindly supplied, Herbie:

    Russia has portrayed the conflict as a struggle against the West, which, it says, wants to remake the world according to its own interests. Zannier said that by sending weapons to Kiev, the West would only strengthen the Russian narrative.

    From you:

    Your view seems to be that Russian concens about this are merely statements of self-interest.

    You also argue that even Kiev’s concerns are self-interested statements to other objectives.

    I’d be very disappointed if my government didn’t act in the country’s interest. (I often am, but that’s another can of worms entirely). Retaining

    I’m just saying that ramping up the nuclear issue serves both sides’ interests to some extent.

    German and Polish ditto. Both have had some Russian occupation, and, inexplicably enough, don’t want any more.

    American? Clearly, they have a considerable investment in European security to protect. Extending NATO protection to Ukraine would be an unwise move IMO, but as Western Ukraine is pretty solidly in the European camp, and borders it, it’s a difficult position.

    At what point should we take concerns about a broader escalation more seriously?

    Right now, of course. In any conflict, that concern is paramount. One way to address that is to stop shooting and negotiate, before it gets any worse. Another other way is to give Russia exactly what it wants. And a third way is to give Ukraine exactly what it wants. Them’s the options, and the rest, from both sides, is exclusively about national interest. I don’t see how you can question that.

    In my own opinion, a wider escalation is unlikely at the moment. The forces (with which Russia consistently denies collaborating – though their supporters here ignore this) are engaged in a low-level war of attrition and infiltration, and both sides recognise that. Russia’s -sorry- the heroic freedom fighters’ objectives include the coastal strip with Mariupol and control of the Donetsk region. Politically and militarily, staking a claim and nibbling away at the margins suits them fine. A full-blown blitzkrieg would risk further escalation…and that’s why they’re not doing it.

1 12 13 14 15 16 55

Comments are closed.